Blogs

#9: Understanding Behaviorism vs. Cognitive Learning: A Holistic Approach

There has been a lot of debate surrounding behaviorism versus cognitive learning. However, it is important to recognize that this topic is much more complex than simply choosing one approach over the other. Both behaviorism and cognitive learning play significant roles in shaping an individual's behavior and learning process. This article aims to shed light on the interconnectedness of these two theories and emphasize the importance of taking a holistic approach to create emotionally happy and well-adjusted individuals, whether they are humans or animals.

Operant conditioning, a fundamental concept in behaviorism, is the process through which individuals learn to operate and navigate their environment. From the moment a baby horse is born, it begins to engage in operant conditioning, learning how to obtain what it wants and avoid what it doesn't. This learning process involves various reinforcers, such as positive reinforcement, punishment, and negative reinforcement. It is crucial to understand that all these components work together to shape behavior and create neural pathways that facilitate easier recall and performance of learned behaviors.

While operant conditioning forms the basis of behaviorism, it is essential to recognize that learning is not solely a behavioral process. It also involves cognitive elements. As individuals learn and experience different situations, their cognitive processes come into play. Neural pathways are formed, making it easier to recall and perform certain behaviors without conscious effort. This cognitive aspect of learning allows individuals to build upon previous knowledge and experiences, making the learning process more efficient.

It is crucial to adopt a holistic approach to training and learning, whether it involves animals or humans. Merely focusing on reinforcers and punishers is insufficient and can be detrimental to the individual's emotional well-being. Positive reinforcement, for example, should not solely revolve around food rewards. It should encompass a broader perspective, aiming to teach problem-solving skills, encourage curiosity, foster independence, and build confidence. The goal is to create a well-rounded individual who thrives in their environment and enjoys the learning process.

One aspect that often gets overlooked is the importance of relaxation. Training should not create a sense of manic behavior or a transactional relationship solely based on obtaining rewards. Instead, it should prioritize relaxation and a sense of enjoyment in the learning process. Reinforcement should come from various sources, including environmental enrichment and the joy of playing the training game. By incorporating relaxation into the training process, individuals can develop a deeper relationship with their trainers and feel more confident and secure in their environment.

Neuroscience and neurobiology studies have shed light on the seeking system, which drives individuals to find the things they desire and need for survival. Positive reinforcement, in the form of food or other resources, taps into this seeking system and creates engagement and excitement. However, it is essential to use positive reinforcement ethically and not solely as a means to an end. The focus should be on creating problem solvers, fostering curiosity, and helping individuals feel safe and confident in their world.

The ongoing debate between behaviorism and cognitive learning should not be approached as an either-or situation. Instead, it is crucial to understand the interconnectedness of these theories and adopt a holistic approach to training and learning. By considering the physical and social environment, identifying the source of behavioral issues, and utilizing positive reinforcement in a thoughtful and ethical manner, we can create emotionally balanced individuals who thrive and enjoy the learning process.